Can The Senate Try An Ex-President?
President Trump, having reached the historic — and infamous — landmark of being impeached twice, now faces trial in the Senate. But unlike the first time, he will no longer be in office. So, does the Senate have the power to try an ex-president on impeachment charges? The Constitution says that after the House of Representatives votes to impeach a president or any other civil officer, the case is sent to the Senate for a trial, which “shall not extend further than to removal from office, and disqualification” from future office. Conviction requires a two-thirds vote, but barring Trump from future office would take only a majority vote. Scholars disagree about what the Founders intended. Harvard law professor Laurence Tribe and University of Texas law professor Stephen Vladeck note that there are six references to impeachment in the Constitution — references that make clear removal is only one of the purposes of impeachment…Former Harvard Law School Dean Martha Minow explains that the court in that 1993 case viewed impeachment as a “political question,” not reviewable by the court because under the Constitution, impeachment “is given over entirely to Congress.” “I don’t think any member of this current court would want to get into this mess,” she adds. “This is one of the most controversial political moments in the history of the United states, dealing with an exceedingly unpopular president but one with devoted followers and a most divided Congress.” “Were the court to insert itself,” she says, “it would put at jeopardy the one thing that the courts has, which is an arm’s distance from the direct political process.”